Jennie didn’t come home from school that Friday afternoon, she always came directly home and her mother was worried. She called the homes of all of her friends on the chance Jennie was with one of them, but none of them knew where she was. They all told her the last time they had seen Jennie was at the corner leading to her house.
Now Jennie’s mother was really worried, Jennie’s white first communion dress and veil was hanging on her door and she was to have used them at the following Sunday mass. Her mother was in tears when she called the Trenton Michigan Police Department, and told them her story.
The police took her story seriously, as they all knew her and her daughter. Trenton at that time was a fairly small town, and everyone knew everyone else and their kids. A policeman came to the house quickly to get a picture of Jennie and copied it for each member of the force and for the volunteers who would help in the search.
They found her body three days later in an abandoned fair grounds behind an old sign lying against a fence. She had been tortured and raped and her nude body shoved behind the sign. An all points bulletin was sent out to the surrounding towns and to every police departments in the state.
A Wyandotte police officer arrested a man who had tried to take a young girl from her front yard, but she screamed and her mother came outside and the man ran away. They called the police right away and they gave them a very good description of the man. The police found him cowering behind a trash barrel and arrested him. They called the Trenton police and invited them to be at the interrogation of the man.
While interrogating him he admitted he had been arrested before for abusing young girls and had just gotten out of jail on parole for the 3rd time. He also confessed to the murder of Jennie and told them where to find the body of another missing young girl in Trenton.
After finding the other body, the Trenton police took him into custody and back to Trenton. As he was getting out of the police car he made a move as if to run away. The police officers told him gruffly to “Run you bastard, we need a good excuse to shoot you!”
He backed up and then pleaded not to be sent back to the Michigan State Prison as he knew the prisoners hated child molesters and he was harassed for all the time he had spent there on his three convictions.
Now we are debating whether repeat offenders should be tried as capital cases. Well, the case above is just one example of why he should have been tried that way the first time. I’ve heard the arguments against capital punishment; they say it’s not a deterrent to crime, and that the Bible says “Thou shall not kill,” That in fact is one of the commandants, and they also quote out of order the verse that says “Vengeance is mine sayeth the lord.” But they forget he also said “He that kills with the sword shall be punished by the sword.”
If capital punishment had been used in that man’s first offence he never would have been paroled 3 times to kill those two girls, and make a try for another. Treating these offenders with kid’s gloves and trying to treat them is a fantasy trip. They are all supposed to register as offenders but I’m sure some don’t or move to other states and continue to offend. When the police notify neighbors a registered offender has moved into their neighborhood, they cry discrimination. Worse yet some misguided citizens back them up.
It isn’t just child killers that should get the death penalty and although many grievous criminals are already on death row, they are allowed to receive, time after time, the chance to appeal and if all else fails to try to get the governors to change their sentences.
Now I know some of those were falsely convicted but they are in the minority, and I truly hope they or their lawyers can get their convictions overturned. Right here in Arizona we have a slew of convicts on death row. They have all spent years on appeals, but unfortunately, ther victims and their survivors have no appeal to the long legal battle allowed to the criminal.
These days, thank God, we have the benefit of crime labs and DNA testing that was lacking when Jennie was murdered. So there isn’t much doubt that those remaining on death row really did the crime. In fact some convicted men have been released because DNA proved they were not guilty.
Don’t try to tell me the death penalty should be outlawed. The argument that it doesn’t prevent crime is false, if that was so why do convicted criminals fear it so much? In the days of the gas chambers and electric chair we may have made a case for cruel and unusual punishment, but at least I think today’s method of putting them to sleep for good is somewhat better. I know it is better treatment than they afforded their victims.
In case you think I made up the story of Jennie, I didn’t, as I lived in Trenton when it occurred. I was in high school at the time and took part in the search for her. Telling her story can still bring a tear to my eyes. By the way, the man who killed her was right, he was sent back to the Michigan Prison with a life sentence and before he had served two years of it was found dead in his cell with signs he had been beaten to death by at least one of the other prisoners. They never found his killer, but I really don’t think they looked too hard for him or them.